Breaking News
More () »

Bodies of 10 Native American students to be returned to living family members

The remains of the children, who died between 1880 and 1910 at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School, will be sent to the closest living descendent.

CARLISLE, Pa. — The remains of 10 children who died at Carlisle Indian Industrial School are scheduled to be exhumed on Thursday, June 17.

The remains of the children, who died between 1880 and 1910, will be sent to the closest living descendent.

One student, Sophia Tetoff, came from the Aleut in Alaska. The other nine—Lucy Take the Tail (Pretty Eagle), Rose Long Face (Little Hawk), Ernest Knocks Off (White Thunder), Dennis Strikes First (Blue Tomahawk), Maud Little Girl (Swift Bear), Friend Hollow Horn Bear, Warren Painter (Bear Paints Dirt), Alvan (Kills Seven Horses), Dora Her Pipe (Brave Bull)—came from the Rosebud Sioux in South Dakota, according to a U.S. Army notice.

Between 1879 and 1918, 9,000 Native American children were taught to assimilate into White American culture. They came from tribes around the country.

“If you took children away from their homes and their family life and isolated them in another space surrounded by the White culture, then you would be able to turn them into Victorian-era White boys and girls,” said Dickinson College archivist James Gerencser.

Carlisle was the first off-reservation boarding school for Native American students. Civil War veteran Lt. Col. Richard Henry Pratt founded the school under the belief that amid Westward Expansion, the only hope for Native American survival was to give up all native cultures and assimilate. He coined the term “Kill the Indian, save the man.”

“There was the saying that ‘The only good Indian was a dead Indian,’” Gerencser said. “Richard Henry Pratt was putting his spin on that and saying, ‘No, rather than killing them, we should be teaching them to be like us.’”

The school was considered a model of educational reform and labeled a “noble experiment.” It launched a movement of similar schools across the U.S. and Canada.

“Carlisle is the first, but this policy affected everyone and it's not well known. It's not in the history books,” said Cara Curtis, archives and library director for the Cumberland County Historical Society.

Children were separated from siblings and forbidden to speak their own language. The drastic change and strict regimen could have led to health issues, historians said, in addition to the risks already imposed by living in crowded boarding school conditions.

“Tuberculosis was the biggest killer,” Gerencser said.

Over 39 years, 186 students died and were buried in Carlisle. About 20 percent of the students who died at school were sent home rather than being buried in Carlisle, sGerencser said.

“They shouldn't have been here. They should have been home with their families and quite possibly they wouldn't have gotten sick and died,” Curtis said.

The Army will conduct the disinterment and return of remains to surviving family members who requested them.

“We should do everything we can to make sure it's a piece of history that doesn't get repeated and we teach about it so people learn from these mistakes,” Gerencser said.

Since 2018, the remains of nine other students have been returned to their surviving family members.

RELATED: Art project honors dead at long-neglected African-American cemetery

RELATED: Bodies of six Native American teenagers returned after disinterment project

Before You Leave, Check This Out